Wednesday, May 04, 2011

ABS-CBN & ANC's "HARAPAN: RH Bill Ipasa o Ibasura" Grand Debate

HARAPAN
RH Bill: Ipasa o Ibasura?
The Grand Debate
May 8, 2011/Sunday/9:15pm – 11pm

Debate Moderators: Julius Babao & Karen Davila


Venue: PDA Hall or Studio 6 (ABS-CBN Compound)


Open Debate: Anti-RH Team Vs. Pro-RH Team on 3 main issues.


*Issue 1: Saan ba nagsisimula ang buhay? (Conception)
Debate Proper I 
Poll Partial Results (Online & Text)



*Issue 2: Responsible Parenthood, Overpopulation, State Intervention & Contraception
Debate Proper II
Fast Facts or Poll Partial Results (Online & Text)



Issues 3: Sex Education, Access/Right to Information, Women’s Rights
Debate Proper III

CONCLUSION: Summary of points raised
FINAL TALLY OF PULSO NG BAYAN (online & text surveys)
---

Anti-RH Panel                                 
Fr. Melvin Castro                     
Rep. Anthony Golez                  
Muslim Youth (?)

Rep. Roilo Golez
Joey Lina
Jo Imbong
Ligaya Acosta
**Christine Jacob Sandejas (not coming)


Pro-RH Panel
Protestant Bishop Tano
Dr. Esperanza Cabral

Rep. Edcel Lagman
Rep. Janette Garin
Carlos Celdran 
Risa Hontiveros-Baraquel
Beth Angsioco
**INC will just send a statement


***
ANNOUNCEMENTS:


There will be 24 seats allocated for both parties. To date, 24 seats are occupied. All 24 pro-RH audience are requested to wear purple and bring campaign paraphernalia.


For those online and TV viewers, please do vote during the entire airing of the program. And let the voices of the people be heard for the RH Bill. Use #proRH as hashtag in Twitter posts. 

33 comments:

  1. Karen Davila ang Julius Babao are both PRO-RH.I will not expect a balance in this event. LIFE IS LIFE and it is not DEBATABLE. OBEY GOD'S WILL.NO TO RH BILL!

    ReplyDelete
  2. How do you know it is not God's will? Who said Life is not life? The greatest ignorance is to reject something you know nothing about.

    ReplyDelete
  3. To anonymous, who ever said Life is not life? Pwede bang basahin mo muna ang bill? Pano maging life ang sperm cells sa loob ng isang condom? Katangahan!

    ReplyDelete
  4. GAnun tlga Jacq... Me mga tao na inuuna arte bago isip. Kaartehan na lang nila yan, d na nag iisip...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with First Knight. Sa nagcomment ng about God's will, WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT GOD'S WILL? Sige nga. We all live to have a good life. And this Bill will be of great help para maachieve natin yun. Dapat talaga nag-iisip muna. At kapag nag-isip, dapat kritikal. :))

    ReplyDelete
  6. sino ang target guest nila sa ANTI-RH na isang MUSLIM YOUTH????????????

    ReplyDelete
  7. hindi kmi sang,ayon sa RH BILL ksi ito ay nakakapatay nang buhay nang kabataang pilipino.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bible quote: Jesus said (to the church), "Whatever you allow on earth will be allowed in heaven. Whatever you do not allow on earth will not be allowed in heaven..." So why not obey the will of the church which is the will of God? Ganyan na ba talaga ang ating gobyerno? isang anti-Christ Government?

    ReplyDelete
  9. well, wala akong alam tungkol sa God's will. pano mo naman nasabi na that RH bill will be a great help to us for achieving a good life? nakikita mo ba ang future. well, kung oo, i'm so proud of you ! :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. para po sa akin hnd po mganda ang turuan ang mga bata tungkol sa RH BILL dahil mas lalo lang silang magkakaroon ng idea how to abort and how to have sex relation,mas maganda po wag ng ipasok sa icp ng bata ang ganitong usapin.

    ReplyDelete
  11. IBASURA ang RH bill dahil hindi ito ang tanging solusyon sa kahirapan...

    ReplyDelete
  12. Those who opposed the RH BILL are like CANCERS in our BODY. Their holier-than-thou attitude annoyed me!! pretending that they never used condoms at all. ill mind.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Enjoyed watching the debate earlier.

    ReplyDelete
  14. DO NOT EVER equate the WILL OF THE CHURCH with the WILL OF GOD. They are two very different entities. God is NOT EQUAL to church. Not even the pope can honestly claim that he knows what the WILL OF GOD is.

    ReplyDelete
  15. kung sino man ang nagsabing nakapapatay ng buhay ang RH bill, katangahan lng yan at walang basehan,,magisip ka nga before you enter what youve encoded.Another point, hindi anti christ ang Rh bill kundi itoy tulong lamang sa mga taong walng masyadong alam sa mga bagay bagay katulad ng pagtuturo ng sexuality sa kanilang anak. Alam naman natin na bumabata na ang mga magulang ngaun,ilan sa kanila ay hindi nakapagaral,kaya ieexpect nyo ba maituturo nila sa mga anak nila ang ganitong usapin kung hindi naman sila nakapagaral ng husto?.Another point, ang Rh bill of help sa mga ata kasi in the first place ang gobyerno ay tumulong lamang sa mga magulang na hindi kayang ipaliwanag ang tungkol sa sexuality and not only sexuality is involved in the bill. Kung iisipin nyo, kahit wala pang Rh bill noon, marami ng nabubuntis na kabatahan dahil sa walng kaalaman patungkol dito.Is this true? BASTA I AM PRO RH BILL, MAGISIP NGA KAYO NG MABUTI, HINDI LAMANG SEXUALITY(SEX EDUCATION) ANG NILALAMAN NITO, HUWAG KAYONG MAGCONCENTRATE LAMANG DITO, MARAMI PANG IBANG NAKAPALOOB SA PANUKALA...i love the debate last night

    ReplyDelete
  16. alam ninyo, sinabi sa bibliya s genesis 1:28 n humayo kayo at mgpakarami ngunit SUPILIN ito. Bkit? sapagkat iniutos lng ito ng Diyos s unang tao dhil nkikita ng Diyos n qng dumating ang araw at sobrang dami n ng tao, konti n ang sasamba s Diyos ksi mghahanap muna ng pagkain at tsaka dadami ang mamamatay dhil s gutom.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Respect each others understanding that means you hindi tayo nawala sa kagustuhan ng panginoon. . ang importante sa likod ng mga nagkakagulong tao sa ating bansa nadoon pa rin ang respeto at pagkakaisa, pagtutulungan at mangingibabaw ang pag-ibig sa bawat isa. .

    ReplyDelete
  18. hindi sagot sa kahirapan ang RH Bill kundi magsumikap tayo. . dito sa Mindanao marami pang mga lupa kahit sa Visayas. . nag invite pa nga tayo ng nga investors at mga foreigner. . at ang mga mambabatas naman ayusin naman ninyo ang ang mga batas na ipapasa ninyo baka ito ang sanhi ng kaguluhan, kahirapan at abuses please REVIEW . . .

    ReplyDelete
  19. littlemiss AYNLA supporterMay 9, 2011 at 3:20 PM

    Good job po sa AYNLA, always there in the action!

    Suggestions lang po...
    Maganda po sana if may mga tarps kau na nagsasabi ng iba't ibang info supporting RH bill in the background.

    We already know you're PRO-RH so you don't need to put it in the camera po. Nababasa namin already sa mga damit nio, sana po next time information na lang yun finaflash nio sa camera and not just the stickers, para naka suporta pa kau in educating the public.

    The underlying purpose of the debate is not for your side to win, but to win the hearts of the TV audience.

    No offense po but malaking distraction ang mga tao sa likod.

    We need to show them that we are upstanding professionals. (I know magastos po but can your group go there in purple long sleeves instead of Tshirts? Suggestion lang nman po, hihi.)

    I understand po your enthusiasm sa issue, but the best we can do is show them an aura of professionalism, unity, and maturity.

    This time nanalo ang PRO-RH audience kasi they carried themselves well. But i know next time we will perform better.

    Will you be at GMA7 debate? Sana po andun rin kau para may mga Nurses parin dun.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Ever wnder y hnd tau nkakakita ng non-catholic na anti-RH? buti nlng protestante family namen.

    dapat kasi ngtanong sila sa mga mahihirap na pamilya bago nagsalita yang mga "expert" na yan.

    Tanungin nila ang single mom nkatira sa lansangan na may 15 anak kung pabor b cia na mgbgyan ng libreng contraceptives nun bata cia.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Pro-LIFE = Pro-QUALITY of LIFEMay 9, 2011 at 3:58 PM

    Let us assume that life starts at Conception (when sperm meets egg). As a Catholic and a Nurse, i believe this.

    With the exception of IUDs, and "morning-after" pills (the ones not available in the PH), the contraceptives in the RH Bill make it so that the sperm and egg don't meet.

    And if you say na masama rin ang pagsasayang ng pre-conception sperm and egg cells thru condom, pills, ligation, etc.,

    bakit ginawa ni God na nagmemenses ang mga babae
    and bakit may nocturnal emissions ang mga lalake? e di hundreds na ang naturally naabort sa isang babae at billions ang naaabort sa isang lalake?

    the contraceptive part in the RHB only makes it na hindi sila magkikita. We do not promote termination after conception. (With the exception of IUDs nga hehe, sana matanggal na yun part na yun, masaya na lahat).

    ReplyDelete
  22. Let LOGIC and Science decideMay 9, 2011 at 4:02 PM

    Kuya A,

    para matahimik na lahat ng tao, please make a table of all arguments of anti-RH on the left, and the pro-RH rebuttals on the right.

    pakilista po lahat ng sinasabi nila sa Harapan, Online, etc.; classify them, tapos make your point.

    para matahimik na sila.
    (from a fan)

    ReplyDelete
  23. BAKIT ANG CHINA NAKAYA NILA (DENSELY POPULATED) . BAKIT ANG INDONESIA (OVER POPULATED- CORRUPT GOVERNMENT). . HINARAP ANG PROBLEMA. . WALANG RH-RH . . .ANG PINAS MARAMI PANG NATURAL RESOURCES BUMIGAY KAAGAD. . SABI NG PANGINOON ANG BABAW NG PANANAPALATAYA. . GOVERNMENT ITS YOUR PROBLEM . . SOLVE THE PROBLEM. . HUWAG PABAYAAN ANG PILIPINO MAGKAWAKAT WAKAT DAHIL SA BATAS NA ISUSULONG NINYO. SINO SA INYO ANG MAKIKINABANG SA BATAS NA YAN. . MAG-ISIP. . DAHIL GINAMIT LANG TAYO AT GINAWANG INSTRUMENTO NI SATANAS. .

    ReplyDelete
  24. SEN ENRILE said - he noted that the Philippines could be rushing the passage of the RH Bill just to meet the United Nations Millennium Development Goals (MDG).

    The MDGs are 8 international development goals that UN member-countries and 23 international organizations have committed to achieve by 2015.

    HUWAG MAGPAGAMIT. . BAYAN. .

    ReplyDelete
  25. Ang problema, HINDI ANG POPULATION, ika nga'y ang system of government... ang corruption.,.

    ang problema dito sa Pinas, pag may mali, we always would like to put a blame on something...

    bakit ang KOReA? Mas marami ang people per density nila compared sa Pinas...

    STOP BLAMING THE POPULATION...

    ReplyDelete
  26. I think Senator Enrile is against RH Bill, He once sited (in Krusada) that it's not just a talk about morality, it is also an issue about the constitution... He said it's anti - constitutional. I forgot the exact words in the said constitution but it goes something like "the protection of women and children from the time of conception"...

    ReplyDelete
  27. i believe in the separation of the church and the state, and god should not be used as an argument in this issue. i am a public health nurse in one of the poorest municipalities. I witnessed mother and newly born babies die in front of me and early age pregnancy suffer physically and emotionally just bec. they have been deprive by the information they need...

    ReplyDelete
  28. all creation is good and that evil is the wrong use of good and that without grace we use it wrong most of the time.We are precious, steward of Gods life. .
    My whole being is given me by GOD...as a source of joy, growth, life, creativity, and fulfillment...not as an arbitrary affliction.
    MAG-ISIP para sa RH Bill kung dapat or hindi. . na hindi tayo makunsensya sa huli. . .

    ReplyDelete
  29. there was a question that "Are we doubting the abilities of our parents to teach their child?" .... the answer is YES! the fact that we are having family planning problems is due to the fact that many of the parents simply are not capable of teaching their child

    ReplyDelete
  30. hindi pweding magkaroon ng rh bill sa pilipinas will hindi ko naman alam yan pero sa tingin ko kasi parang nakadagdag problema

    ReplyDelete
  31. Great Philosopher:

    hello dear...wala sa mga sinabi niyo ang issue na ini-isip ko....its not about god and its not about contraception because all of you had a great misconception..

    ang sa akin lang naman....kung totoo na hindi mandatory yung rh bill bakit kailangan may offense pa para sa mga tao na hindi sumunod....and in fact kung hindi lahat ang sumusunod sa batas na ito what is the sense of calling this a bill..Remember a bill s for evryone...


    mayroon pa...pati yong sex education:

    sinabi ni rza honteveros na hindi rin yo mandatory sa mga estudyante na magkaroon ng sex education pero mandatory sa mga paaralan na magkaroon ng ganoong curriculum....so again..wats the sense of calling sex education as one of the curriculums in school kung hindi lahat nang estudyante may ganitong education....DUH!!!!! mag-sip nga kayoong laht...



    hindi pa man nakapag meet ang sperm cell at egg cell pero nandoon parin ang sense na pinipigilan niyo silang mag meet....


    To call it “Reproductive Health Bill” is a big distortion. Reason: the Bill is not “reproductive” simply because it is against reproduction.


    LIFE IS LIFE and it is not DEBATABLE. OBEY GOD'S WILL.NO TO RH BILL!

    ReplyDelete
  32. Great Philosopher:

    i had just remember of what my teacher said to me for the people who are pro in rh bill

    They love the pleasure but they dont want to have a responsibilty cause they prevent theirselves of having an output through sex.....Du!!!

    ReplyDelete
  33. great philosopher:

    all creation is good and that evil is the wrong use of good and that without grace we use it wrong most of the time.We are precious, steward of Gods life. .
    My whole being is given me by GOD…as a source of joy, growth, life, creativity, and fulfillment…not as an arbitrary affliction.

    ReplyDelete